The ideal venue for a conversation about this would be a good

Walter Kaufmann religion versus reason Why Evolution Is True

canada goose store This one, from pp. 220 221, is on the incompatibility between religion canada goose outlet 2015 and reason. (I don agree with the first sentence of the third paragraph if by it Kaufmann is agreeing to some extent with religion claim that we can know things about the universe without using empirical methods.) canada goose store

canada goose uk outlet In one way, morality will soon go the way of astronomy, physics, and biology: to be sure, it will not canada goose victoria parka outlet become a science; but Christians, too, will soon concede the need for rational discussion canada goose outlet of moral questions as well as the relevance of observation and then Christianity will adopt the position that morality canada goose outlet reviews is not of ultimate significance. Today, some Christians may still object: if morality is not of ultimate significance, what is? But it is far from self evident that rules about permissible and impermissible sexual relations should be more crucial for religion than whether the earth revolves around the sun or whether man is a cousin of the gorilla. canada goose uk outlet

Reason and observation alone will never tell us what to canada goose outlet eu do and how to live; whom, if anybody, we should marry; or how many, if any, children we should want. But it does not follow that religion must answer these questions. Nor does canada goose vest outlet it minimize the crucial distinction between informed and uninformed decisions or between responsible and irresponsible choices.

Christianity has canada goose parka outlet been right in insisting on the limitations of reason and observation; but it has vastly exaggerated them while failing to recognize its own limitations: again and again it has claimed competence in areas where it had none. And from the very beginning it has conceived itself as an enemy of reason and worldly wisdom; it has exerted itself to impede the development of reason, belittled the achievements of reason, and gloated over the setbacks of reason.

canada goose black friday sale In principle, many outstanding Roman Catholic thinkers have maintained that reason and religion need not be enemies but canada goose outlet in usa could be complementary. But the peace effected by Roman Catholicism was based on the enslavement of reason, upon its employment in the service of propositions which it was not allowed to question. The vaunted synthesis of reason and faith depended on the stake. When the stake lost its tyrannical effectiveness, the revolve of reason and the long war between reason and faith came to dominate the intellectual history of the canada goose outlet factory West for centuries. It has made a supreme canada goose outlet germany virtue of unquestioning docility. But what alternative remains where reason and observation are ruled out of court? canada goose black friday sale

Reason and observation alone will never tell us what to do and how to live; whom, if anybody, we should marry; or how many, if any, children we should want.

This would be true, but it is not the whole truth and deceptively so.

canada goose If you desire any of a number of very common and sensible things for a human to desire, then you can make conclusions about all those things and more. canada goose

Canada Goose online There are selfish personal gains to be had from marriage and children companionship, sharing of workloads, satisfying the evolutionarily instilled desire to pass on one genes. Tax benefits, even. There are also losses, too loss of privacy and independence, for example, in addition to a financial burden. Canada Goose online

cheap Canada Goose Reason is perfectly suited to weighing those advantages and disadvantages in general, and further in the specific to, for example, decide if a certain potential spouse is the right one. cheap Canada Goose

Canada Goose Coats On Sale While it may be true that it is ultimately necessary to take certain first principles as a given, as axioms, so what? Everything else can be readily enough derived from those first principles, in much the same way that all of geometry is derived from not all that many initial axioms. What matter other than idle curiosity that uncommon (and often self defeating) initial premises lead to different conclusions? Objecting on such grounds is as silly as suggesting that you can somehow a great circle navigation route from San Francisco to Hong Kong over the Aleutian Islands because, if the Earth were aspherical then the shortest distance would be something else. So what? The Earth is (basically) a sphere, and great circle routes save time, fuel, and money. Hypothetical alternate geometries are as irrelevant there as are hypothetical alternate initial premises canada goose outlet paypal for morality. Canada Goose Coats On Sale

buy canada goose jacket cheap One of the best parts in the book, canada goose jacket outlet uk is the section which deals with a dialogue between Satan, God and an Atheist. Following is an excerpt which is cool:Satan: I still do not understand what it is that, you think, exists, or in what way it exists. Does canada goose shop uk God take up space as you do? buy canada goose jacket cheap

buy canada goose jacket Satan: Why, then, do you say that he exists? buy canada goose jacket

Canada Goose Jackets Christian: Surely, many things exist that do not goose outlet canada take up space. Canada Goose Jackets

Christian: Does a dream take up space? Or a feeling? Or a thought?

canada goose uk black friday Satan: Is God a dream, a feeling, or a thought? canada goose uk black friday

canada goose factory sale Haidt in Righteous Mind: canada goose outlet canada Why canada goose clothing uk Good People Are Divided by Politics and Religion pretty much pulls the stool out from under both and when it comes to All one needs is a dash of Dual Process canada goose outlet vip Theory a la Kahneman, slather in a bit of Moral Foundations Theory, and a pinch research that Haidt et al. have done, some appreciation for the canada goose outlet in vancouver evolutionary pressures/constraints on individuals who are members of social species, and, Bob your uncle: (moral) come first, strategic reasoning second. Evolution wires us up to moral, or to do what necessary to insure the survival of the individuals and group structure upon which we (the individual members of the social species and group) depend for our survival. canada goose factory sale

I digress. All of the Abrahamic canada goose outlet in canada religions would have one believe that religion canada goose outlet black friday determines the morality. Haidt shows just the opposite. comes first, then comes the need to justify the position. Many have taken the position that we (homo sapiens) have created religion in our own image. Haidt work pretty much shoves it in canada goose outlet nyc the face of religion.

canada goose clearance There is no way to do this topic justice in this small place. Nothing is ever as simple as it seems… this especially. I just canada goose outlet mall wanted to throw the gauntlet down… canada goose clearance

canada goose coats I haven read the book, although I have read about the book. I am skeptical about some of Haidt canada goose premium outlet conclusions as I understand them. canada goose coats

cheap canada goose uk Problem 1. The morality comes first conclusion is contradicted by the facts that morality is rooted in how the world works and we can understand how the world works canada goose outlet houston only by observation and reason. As a result, morality is dependent on, and thus second in sequence and relative to, reason. cheap canada goose uk

canada goose clearance sale Problem 2. Conservatives have a more complete and balanced, and therefore better morality than liberals is based on the claim that all six of the value pairs that Haidt singles out as underlying morality have equal merit. So the liberal approach of canada goose outlet hong kong splitting these foundations into tiers and placing Care/harm and Fairness/cheating into the upper tier while placing the latter two pairs into the lower tier results in better morality. Haidt is mistaken to insist tat all six foundations have equal merit. canada goose clearance sale

Hola Explicit Atheist I really not trying to be a wise ass when I say this, but canada goose outlet locations in toronto I would encourage you to read the book and see if you feel the same way after having read it. This isn the canada goose outlet online uk place for a book review so I won do this. I understand what you saying, but I strongly believe that what you saying is based on an incomplete understanding of what he is saying. I am going to resist the temptation to go into detail about why I think that because this is not the venue for it. These comments must be brief and in this situation, the cost of brevity would be the loss of nuance and this is a fairly nuanced topic. The ideal venue for a conversation about this would be a good microbrewery somewhere…

canada goose coats on sale If you are interested enough in the topic to invest the time in reading Righteous Mind, I would encourage you to do so. In the end, it is of no import at all where you end up in your thinking. I can guarantee that the journey will be most interesting canada goose coats on sale.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *